Father James Riley came to the Catholic parish in Miles City, Montana, under very unusual circumstances. To the parish pastor, Riley's arrival was a godsend. However, retired journalist Josh Cody was suspicious of the circumstances by which the young priest showed up seemingly out of nowhere. Cody's suspicions grew exponentially after the murders of two young girls in a span of less than six months in a town that experienced a murder about once every decade. While local authorities are at a standstill trying to solve the murders, Cody launches his own investigation all while befriending the priest. "Prey for Me" pulls back the curtain on the inner workings of the Catholic Church exposing the ongoing efforts to bury its systemic sins.